Licensed Indiana Plumber — IN #CO52500055 · Serving Carmel, Fishers & North Indy

Water Heater Repair & Replacement

No hot water on a weekday morning is a bad start. We repair and replace gas and electric tank water heaters, install and service tankless units, and give you a straight answer on whether a repair still makes sense or it's time for a new one. Our customers often tell us we saved them from a replacement another company said they needed.

Same-day replacement · Bradford White tank and Navien tankless · Permit and haul-away included · 16-month warranty when you mention our website. Replacement guide →

5.0★Google Rating
10%Price Match Guarantee
On-siteOptions Before Work

What we do

Water heater repair and replacement

For homes and businesses in Carmel, Fishers, North Indianapolis and across Hamilton County.

Water heater repair (gas and electric)

Request service →

Tank water heater replacement, all common sizes

Request service →

Tankless water heater installation, upgrades and descaling

Tankless repair & installation →

Pilot, thermocouple, gas valve and element repair

Request service →

Expansion tanks, T&P valves and code upgrades

Request service →

Commercial water heaters

Request service →

Water heater repair

Common water heater repairs

Gas and electric, tank and tankless, across Carmel, Fishers and North Indianapolis.

No hot water

We check the gas valve, pilot or igniter on gas heaters, and the elements and thermostats on electric ones.

Leaking water heater

A leaking relief valve or drain valve can often be repaired. A leaking tank usually means it is time to replace it.

Rusty or brown hot water

Often a worn anode rod or sediment in the tank. Read the guide →

Rotten egg smell

Usually a reaction between the anode rod and your water. Read the guide →

Tankless water heater repair

Error codes, scale buildup and no-heat calls on tankless units.

Tankless water heater repair →

Repair or replace?

Age, the type of problem and the cost of the fix all matter. Read the guide →

Repair first

Water heater repair by type

Most no-hot-water calls are a repair, not a new heater. Here is what usually goes wrong on each kind and what we check.

Gas water heater repair

Pilot that will not stay lit, a failed thermocouple or igniter, a bad gas control valve or a burner choked with dust. We test each one and replace the part that failed.

Pilot light guide →

Electric water heater repair

Lukewarm water or none at all usually means a burned-out heating element or a failed thermostat. Both can be replaced without replacing the tank.

See an electric job →

Power vent water heater repair

Power vent units add a blower motor, a pressure switch and a control board. When one of those fails the heater locks out. We diagnose which part it is before anything gets replaced.

Power vent vs. direct vent →

Tankless water heater repair

Error codes, ignition and flame problems, venting, condensate and scale. Our plumbers are Navien-trained, and a yearly flush prevents most of it.

Tankless repair & installation →

Leaks, relief valves and connections

A drip at a fitting, a weeping relief valve or a failed expansion tank can be repaired. A tank leaking from the bottom cannot, and we will tell you which one you have.

Leaking from the bottom? →

When repair stops making sense

Rusty water from the hot side, a leaking tank or a heater well past ten years that keeps needing parts. That is when we show you replacement options next to the repair.

Repair vs. replacement →

Warning signs

Signs your water heater needs attention

If you notice any of these, it’s worth a call.

  • No hot water, or it runs out fast
  • Water around the base of the tank
  • Rusty or brown hot water
  • Rotten-egg smell from the hot water
  • Popping or rumbling from the tank
  • The tank is 10 or more years old

How pricing works

Options and a price before any work starts

We check the unit, the venting, the gas or electric supply and the shutoffs on site. Then we lay out your options (repair, replace, or upgrade to tankless) and give you a price for each before any work starts.

Why homeowners call us

  • Licensed (IN #CO52500055), insured and background-checked
  • Honest repair-vs-replace advice
  • Options and a price before we start
  • Same-day service for most calls
  • 10% price match on any written competitor quote
Schedule water heater service
Avg. response timeSame day / next day
Service areaHamilton County & North Indy
LicenseIN #CO52500055
PricingOptions on site, before work
ExpertPipe Indy technicians setting a new water heater
Setting a new water heaterTwo techs carrying in and setting a new tank.
Gas water heater with expansion tank and PVC venting next to a furnace
Gas water heater installExpansion tank, copper connections and PVC venting.
Old water heater removed and loaded for haul-away
Old tank hauled awayWe remove and dispose of the old water heater.

Helpful guides

Guides for homeowners

Straight answers from licensed plumbers. See all guides →

Water Heater Replacement: What to Expect

Read the guide →

Water Heater Leaking? What to Do Before It Floods Your Basement

Read the guide →

How Hard Water Shortens the Life of Your Water Heater

Read the guide →

Tankless Water Heaters: Are They Worth It?

Read the guide →

Water Heater Installation in Meridian Hills & North Indy

Read the guide →

What Size Water Heater Do I Need?

Read the guide →

Common questions

Water Heater Repair & Replacement FAQs

How long do water heaters last in Indiana?

Most tank heaters last 8 to 12 years. Hard water shortens that, which is why flushing and a softener help.

Should I repair or replace my water heater?

If the tank itself is leaking, it needs to be replaced. Most other problems, like a bad element or gas valve, can be repaired. We'll tell you which.

Is tankless worth it?

For larger households or homes that run out of hot water, often yes. We'll size one for your home and explain the gas and venting work.

Can you replace it the same day?

In most cases, yes, for standard tank sizes.

Is it worth repairing an old water heater?

Most tank water heaters last about 8 to 12 years. A repair makes sense on a younger unit. If the tank is leaking or near the end of its life, replacing it usually saves money.

Do you repair tankless water heaters?

Yes. We repair and service tankless water heaters, including error codes, scale buildup and no-heat problems.

Can you replace my water heater the same day?

Usually, yes. We offer same-day water heater replacement across Carmel, Fishers, Westfield, Noblesville, Zionsville and North Indianapolis.

What water heater brands do you install?

We install Bradford White tank water heaters and Navien tankless water heaters.

Can a water heater be repaired instead of replaced?

Often, yes. Thermocouples, igniters, gas valves, heating elements, thermostats, relief valves and power vent blowers can all be replaced. A tank that is leaking from the bottom cannot be repaired.

Why do I have no hot water?

On a gas heater it is usually the pilot, thermocouple, igniter or gas valve. On an electric heater it is usually a heating element or thermostat. On a tankless unit, check the display for an error code and call or text us with it.

Do you repair power vent water heaters?

Yes. We diagnose and repair power vent water heaters, including blower motors, pressure switches and control boards, and we replace them when a repair no longer makes sense.

What warranty do you give on water heater installs?

Our standard workmanship warranty is 12 months. Mention our website when you book a water heater replacement and we extend it to 16 months, on top of the manufacturer’s warranty. We also handle the permit and haul away the old water heater.

Local service

Water heater repair and replacement by town

Our shop is in the heart of Carmel, so most of Hamilton County, Boone County and North Indianapolis is a short drive.

Carmel

Same-day water heater repair and replacement from a plumber based in Carmel.

Carmel water heaters →

Westfield

Gas, electric and power vent water heaters across Westfield.

Westfield water heaters →

Fishers

Repair first when it makes sense, same-day replacement when it does not.

Fishers water heaters →

Noblesville

Very hard water is rough on heaters here. We repair, flush and replace.

Noblesville water heaters →

Zionsville

City water and well homes, tank and tankless.

Zionsville water heaters →

North Indianapolis

Meridian Hills, Nora, Broad Ripple and the north side.

Indianapolis water heaters →

Whitestown

Newer homes and builder-grade tanks, repaired or replaced the same day.

Whitestown water heaters →

Brownsburg

Gas, electric, power vent and tankless across Brownsburg.

Brownsburg water heaters →

Cicero

Cicero and the homes around Morse Reservoir.

Cicero water heaters →

McCordsville

Repair first when it makes sense, replacement when it does not.

McCordsville water heaters →

No hot water?

Call or text for same-day service. We’ll give you options and a price on site.

Call (317) 731-3028